Parts Department

Welcome to Our Parts Department

Whether it’s just cruising, chasing the horizon, or just a little bit of both – let our knowledgeable staff assist you with all your parts and accessory inquiries. Customizing your motorcycle? We customize all the time. Let us help you design yours today!

O’Toole’s Harley-Davidson® Motorcycle Parts in Wurtsboro, NY near Newburgh, Middletown, Orange County, and Hudson Valley, NY!

Stop by O’Toole’s Harley-Davidson® to find the missing piece to your motorcycle! Our knowledgeable staff will help you customize your Harley® motorcycle and will gladly assist you in all your accessory inquiries. If you have a specific motorcycle part you’re on the hunt for, then our staff will gladly check to see if we have it in stock or order it for you! We want to make your visit to O’Toole’s Harley-Davidson® as hassle-free as possible – because we know that no two rides should ever be alike, and with thousands of Harley-Davidson® parts and accessories to work with, you’re FREE to create the motorcycle of your dreams. Please submit a service appointment or parts request below by just filling out a brief form and we will get back to you! Come by our motorcycle parts center located in Wurtsboro, NY near Newburgh, Middletown, Orange County, and Hudson Valley, NY!

Online Parts Orders

O’Toole’s Harley-Davidson® Parts Department has been serving New York’s Hudson Valley for over 40 years. Whether you are looking for OEM, Genuine Motor Accessory, or aftermarket parts, our courteous and knowledgeable staff will help you with your needs. We stock thousands of Genuine Harley-Davidson® parts along with aftermarket parts as well. Whether you need basic maintenance items or want to transform your Harley® into a show bike we can help. When you’re riding you need to be comfortable. That’s why our Trained H-D® customization experts will take you through a step-by-step process literally seating you on a bike and switching out components such as seat, handlebars, suspension and foot controls until we find the combination that fits you. This way you know you’ll be comfortable before you make a purchase.

Do you sell aftermarket parts?

Yes. We do sell a selection of aftermarket parts.

What Happens After I Order a Part?

If you know the name or part number of your part, please use our online form to place an order. Otherwise, feel free to call (845) 888 2426 ext. 4 and a specialist will determine exactly what you need. Upon submitting your information we will:

  • Respond to you promptly via your preferred contact method.
  • Ask any additional questions required to identify your parts request.
  • Confirm your order and pricing.

Buy parts directly from Harley-Davidson® and they ship to O’Toole’s Harley-Davidson® for free!

  • Simply select O’Toole’s Harley-Davidson® as your preferred dealer of choice
  • Confirm your order and pricing
  • Should you need to return your purchase, no worries O’Toole’s Harley-Davidson® will gladly do it for you!
  • Stop in, with your customer receipt and return(s). The Harley-Davidson® Motorcompany is responsible for processing your charge back on your customer account.

If you have any questions about what parts you need, fill out the simple form below and our technicians will get back to you.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Dealer Info

    Parts Info

    Phone Number:Parts Hours:
    • Tue - Fri9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
    • Sat9:00 AM - 3:30 PM
    • Mon, SunClosed

    O'Toole's Harley-Davidson is located at: 4 Sullivan St. • Wurtsboro, NY 12790
    O'Toole's Harley-Davidson 41.566890, -74.480350.